British Tennis Forum - Celebrating 20 Years!

Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
British Tennis Forum -> General tennis discussion -> Have your say regarding Player of the Month
Post Info TOPIC: Have your say regarding Player of the Month
Have your say on Player of the Month voting! [45 vote(s)]

I always vote as a monthly priority
24.4%
I do vote if I remember each month
28.9%
I sometimes vote but it depends on the players that month and how much they interest me
15.6%
I vote occasionally but only if I stumble across it
11.1%
I don't vote - it doesn't interest me really
11.1%
I would vote but would like some things to change
0.0%
I didn't even know it existed! Where do I find it?!
4.4%
It has had it's moment - let it die away!!
4.4%
JonH


Tennis legend

Status: Online
Posts: 54163
Date:
Have your say regarding Player of the Month
Permalink  

Given the vote closes this afternoon, it seems unlikely we will get a sudden influx of votes, although votes and comments are welcome.

Im not entirely sure what the vote told me! Although it seems on balance, there is a core group of maybe 20 / 25 people who really value it and more who take part when they can, which is what takes us to our regular votes in the mid 30s. As to what would get us back to votes in the 40s, that isnt clear to me, but this is what I took from the comments:

1) that people find the nominations threads surprisingly- to me- a valuable and interesting resource, more than I had realised and like that part of the process, maybe more appealing than the voting for many
2) keeping that together as one thread each month works best as it puts all comments and nominations in one place and makes it richer (my interpretation)
3) in terms of the vote one though thrown out was to hold separate mens and womens votes, although others commented they would prefer to maintain a single vote
4) it was suggested by a couple of people to leave the vote longer which may allow more people to vote in it
5) it was commented as to whether having its own section had actually led to a reduction in votes.

I am not sure if Ive missed any other ideas, but this is largely what I took from it.

Its great that the nominations process works for people; and its great that enough people like it to make it worth continuing.

For items 3 to 5 above, I will dwell on those more. Item 3 wont change this year, but between now and year end, Ill probably consult further to see what opinion generally is on that specific question.

Regarding its own section on the forum - my feeling is to leave it like that; enough people dont engage with the process that I dont want to bother them by throwing it into general and it feels like the curation process that the nominations and voting leads to is valuable enough to keep it separate

Leaving a vote up longer is easy to accomplish and it is trial and error really to see what works best. Ive left it 1 1/2 days or 2 days in the past, Indy did 2 1/2 days last month. Shorter votes were intended to make it more exciting, ie more vibrant, but going forwards I might play with vote durations and see what happens.

The main question to be considered separately seems to be men and women together in one vote or in separate votes. It will certainly remain for 2026 as it is, further consultation to come towards year end re 2027.

If anyone else got any further insight from this or still wants to comment , the vote closes this afternoon but comments will still be possible for as long as people wish to make them.

Thanks all so far!


__________________
Canda


Lower Club Player

Status: Offline
Posts: 195
Date:
Permalink  

One of the great things about this forum is the respect given to all our players and the acknowledgement that our players are all at different stages in their tennis careers. The player of the month reflects the knowledge in depth of our players and the experience of the members to recognise players' achievements. It is this aspect that makes player of the month so fascinating. Occasionally it is about a player having a great run in a Grand Slam or a Masters where our praise is obvious and well-deserved, but more often we are rewarding the achievements of eg. a player stepping up a level to Challengers maybe, or a successful return from injury or a new career high after a period in the doldrums or consistency at a higher level when results perhaps before were rather sporadic.
This shows that we recognise the level of all our players, whether juniors, men, women, doubles, wheelchair and appreciate their different pathways.
I would be strongly against segregating the player of the month into separate sexes/disciplines for that reason.

__________________
JonH


Tennis legend

Status: Online
Posts: 54163
Date:
Permalink  

Canda wrote:

One of the great things about this forum is the respect given to all our players and the acknowledgement that our players are all at different stages in their tennis careers. The player of the month reflects the knowledge in depth of our players and the experience of the members to recognise players' achievements. It is this aspect that makes player of the month so fascinating. Occasionally it is about a player having a great run in a Grand Slam or a Masters where our praise is obvious and well-deserved, but more often we are rewarding the achievements of eg. a player stepping up a level to Challengers maybe, or a successful return from injury or a new career high after a period in the doldrums or consistency at a higher level when results perhaps before were rather sporadic.
This shows that we recognise the level of all our players, whether juniors, men, women, doubles, wheelchair and appreciate their different pathways.
I would be strongly against segregating the player of the month into separate sexes/disciplines for that reason.

 Thank you Canda - well written and argued. Being honest, it articulates much more clearly where my head has been at (is at) than I would or could do. I am and continue to be keen to hear all arguments though and will probably raise it for a specific discussion nearer the end of the season and before we start 2027.

2026 will carry on as is, rest easy on that!



__________________
JonH


Tennis legend

Status: Online
Posts: 54163
Date:
Permalink  

So this vote closed- thanks to all who had a say, some really interesting feedback and a lot of it around the nominations process, which is great to see, and not just the votes.

Will make something of it all per above. For now, if you want to nominate someone for July, here is where to go to

britishtennis.activeboard.com/t73009092/british-tennis-forum-july-2026-player-of-the-month-nominatio/

Thanks all

__________________
JonH


Tennis legend

Status: Online
Posts: 54163
Date:
Permalink  

From Helen40 - I believe Helen40 is referring to the log I maintain of which player wins PoM, to also add the reason they won?

Please feel free to move this post admin - I wanted to post it on the discussion about PoM but can't find it!

Anyway, want to say that something like this would be great for me but with having the addition a summary of why each player/pair won.

__________________
«First  <  1 2 3 4 | Page of 4  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.
British Tennis Forum -> General tennis discussion -> Have your say regarding Player of the Month
Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse 		Powered by ActiveBoard