Greatest Players of All Time - according to Tennis Abstract

JonH comes home · Tennis legend

Greatest Players of All Time - according to Tennis Abstract

JonH comes home · Tennis legend

And this which rates GOAT points

www.ultimatetennisstatistics.com/goatList

It has Djoko at #1 (men only) but has its own ELO rating that differs somewhat from Jeff's

JonH comes home · Tennis legend

In 11th slot, we have Monica Seles, she was my number 20 but I totally get those who rate her much higher

JonH comes home · Tennis legend

Gameover also had Seles 20th, Exre went for 14th. So we all under-rated her a little.

Keen to read the narrative!

JonH comes home · Tennis legend

www.tennisabstract.com/blog/2022/11/30/the-tennis-128-no-11-monica-seles/

JonH comes home · Tennis legend

Seles had a massively high PEAK ELO in the 2500 plus range, not sure if she had any women higher than her in that measure? Her career of 14 years was surprisingly long but a bit dormant for a while for obvious reasons, so maybe took her ranking in the GOAT stakes down a few places?

GAMEOVER · Satellite level

JonH comes home wrote:
In 11th slot, we have Monica Seles, she was my number 20 but I totally get those who rate her much higher

To me Monica didn't seem to be around long enough for this high rating. She won all the other majors but Steffi was still best at Wimbledon1992.I don't think it would it have made any difference to the result but Monica's cause at Wimbledon 1992 was not helped by Tauziat's protests about her grunting.

Exre · Improver

JonH comes home wrote:
Seles had a massively high PEAK ELO in the 2500 plus range, not sure if she had any women higher than her in that measure?

I think only Graf's peak Elo was definitely even higher (Her peak Elo will have been 2600+). But possibly also Navratilova.

-- Edited by Exre on Wednesday 30th of November 2022 06:20:59 PM

jsackmann · Social player

>I think only Graf's peak Elo was definitely even higher (Her peak Elo will have been 2600+). But possibly also Navratilova.

Yep, ranked by peak:

1. graf (yep, just over 2,600)
2. navratilova
3. seles
4. serena
5. hingis
6. venus
7. evert
8. davenport

5 through 8 are extremely close.

(that doesn't count Wills and Lenglen ... as I mentioned a bit in the Lenglen piece, I used to alternative approach to get them on the same scale, because Elo doesn't really capture the level of someone on a 100-match win streak. They'd both be at least ahead of Hingis, maybe higher.)

top men are

1. borg
2. djokovic
3. mcenroe
4. lendl
5. federer
6. nadal
7. connors

5 through 7 are pretty close.

-- Edited by jsackmann on Thursday 1st of December 2022 08:35:34 AM

JonH comes home · Tennis legend

jsackmann wrote:
>I think only Graf's peak Elo was definitely even higher (Her peak Elo will have been 2600+). But possibly also Navratilova.

Yep, ranked by peak:

1. graf (yep, just over 2,600)
2. navratilova
3. seles
4. serena
5. hingis
6. venus
7. evert
8. davenport

5 through 8 are extremely close.
(that doesn't count Wills and Lenglen ... as I mentioned a bit in the Lenglen piece, I used to alternative approach to get them on the same scale, because Elo doesn't really capture the level of someone on a 100-match win streak. They'd both be at least ahead of Hingis, maybe higher.)

top men are

1. borg
2. djokovic
3. mcenroe
4. lendl
5. federer
6. nadal
7. connors

5 through 7 are pretty close.

-- Edited by jsackmann on Thursday 1st of December 2022 08:35:34 AM

Thanks Jeff - I noticed the ultimate tennis statistics site linked above has an ELO number as well - their numbers seem slightly higher per player than yours , any idea why they differ in the numbers they produce ? I guess it isnt an exact science !

jsackmann · Social player

>their numbers seem slightly higher per player than yours , any idea why they differ in the numbers they produce ? I guess it isnt an exact science !

yeah. the "official" Elo formula has a parameter (the "k factor") that varies depending on the sport. It's possible we're using slightly different numbers for that. I've also added some things, like a penalty for injuries and other absences. I believe they've done the same, but they might not be implemented exactly the same way.

JonH comes home · Tennis legend

11th in the list is, as suspected, Helen Wills .

www.tennisabstract.com/blog/2022/12/01/the-tennis-128-no-10-helen-wills/

JonH comes home · Tennis legend

I had her at 18 whereas Gameover and exre at 6 and 7 respectively.

Ill need to read her bio but 11 feels a good place and the top 10 (5 men and 5 women) come over the course of December

GAMEOVER · Satellite level

JonH comes home wrote:
I had her at 18 whereas Gameover and exre at 6 and 7 respectively.

Ill need to read her bio but 11 feels a good place and the top 10 (5 men and 5 women) come over the course of December

I think it is 10 not 11 for Wills Moody,

JonH comes home · Tennis legend

GAMEOVER wrote:
JonH comes home wrote:
I had her at 18 whereas Gameover and exre at 6 and 7 respectively.

Ill need to read her bio but 11 feels a good place and the top 10 (5 men and 5 women) come over the course of December
I think it is 10 not 11 for Wills Moody,

Youre right - the clue is on the link! Haha