Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Week 21 - French Open (Roland-Garros) - Paris, France (clay) - women's qualifying


All-time great

Status: Offline
Posts: 5404
Date:
RE: Week 21 - French Open (Roland-Garros) - Paris, France (clay) - women's qualifying


indiana wrote:

Yes, there is no particular time in the open era where we can say we were generally particularly better off overall and we have often been worse off.

What's disappoiting is that we have had a historically pretty big batch of players of similarish age coming through together and two or three years ago there seemed promise of progress towards clearly the best group we have had in many decades.

It is disappointing that general progression has not been as hoped for them at ages where it was not unreasonable to expect more progession. And I too would thus question some of the coaching for this. Though I agree that whether GB women are intrinsically more inconsistent is debatable. Women tennis players are inconsistent everywhere as are very many men tennis players.


 Yes, it's just on the face of it the stronghold of Nadal/Djokovic/Federer and to the lesser extent, Murray have hidden this whereas the women's side of things is a lot more turn about, with random women peaking (Ostapenko) and only a few active players holding more than two slams (exl the Williams sisters, I think it's just Kerber and Osaka)



__________________


Tennis legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 10074
Date:

I'll generally be as critical as most on this forum, and of course it's a bit disappointing when you see the rankings at Wimbledon 3 years, and then see them now, regarding that young group of players:

rankings GB.png

 

I know there was a lot of future circumstances around most of these players I'll be mentioning, but on paper, the likes of Katie S, just turned 19, won a Wimbledon main draw match, comfortably inside the top 200, looking decent, then 3 years later she's about 100 places lower down, Gabi completely out of the picture now. Even Harriet, she's had that great run at Wimbledon, qualified for a lot of slams, and has been one of the better GB players to follow in recent years, but on paper, she's moved up about 20 places in 3 years, pushing 25, and has upcoming points to defend. Katie B about 100+ places lower 3 years on, you kind of forget about Katy D as she's hardly played in a year, but even then, 'just' 23 y/o, so younger than the likes of Harriet and Katie B are now, and just outside the top 200, but that's as good as it got for her at that stage. Maia's not much further forward, and the likes of Beth, Alicia etc. have kind of just naturally sifted towards the W15 600/700 range, Freya kind of the same (albeit still a few years younger), but her stock has certainly decreased massively as well. Laura isn't a factor anymore, Naomi's shifting towards a doubles player. Emily Ap lower ranked 3 years later. 

Fran (particularly) and Jodie have generally been a fairly bright spark these past couple of years, and their stock is a lot higher, Emma too, when she plays, although I can't help but feel a lot on here will be pinning their hopes on her in terms of realistic top 50 type players like we have had with Jo, Heather, and Laura. I'm sure that's what Heather was meaning at that rant the last year, not the likes of Matilda and Emma (who was 17 at the time), but the next batch of actual top 50, or even top 100 quality players - there's 11 years difference between Heather and Emma, but there's not many candidates between them.

So yes, I can see where Chris is coming from. While there's obviously been loads of unfortunate injuries, COVID, mental health problems, and other issues, at that stage in 2018 we did look like we could have around 5 youngish players go against the historical grain and push on and crack the top 100, especially while they were still commercially hot, and that's not really happened, and it's probably more going to be passing top 100 visits if they actually get there now, rather than fully establishing themselves as solid 60-90 players for a number of years, getting their names out a bit more with the general public, and taking advantage of any lucrative endorsement offers that come their way, but it's slightly different if you're 27 than if you were properly breaking through at 23/24, which looked quite likely 3 years ago.

That said, general landscape aside, I don't see anything wrong with these RG results thus far - Harriet had a very good win, Fran had an extremely tough draw, like awful, Jodie was also up against it today (although she did have a few actual disappointing results heading into today), and if we're pinning our hopes on 33 year Sam, with one of the lowest profiles you'll see, then there really are problems, ha.

Hopefully Harriet can qualify again now that her draw has opened up a bit, so that she will have played in every slam main draw, and then it can just take a few surprise grass wins, like we had plenty of in 2018, and things can start to look a bit more rosier again.

 



Attachments
__________________


Junior player

Status: Offline
Posts: 65
Date:

Other countries may have the same problems but its GB girls I follow. Have done since the early 70s when I fell in love with Evonne Goolagong although she was Australian. So I have heard the same thing for a long time. Seen a lot of tennis and a lot of GB girls. Frustrating because they do have talent just not the ability to get the wins that we all hope for. Would like to see Harriet up there again and pushing into the top 100. What do you think of a coach out there somewhere teaching the art of serve and volley. Use to really enjoy watching that. Its how I use to play, still do just a bit slower. Thanks for letting me have my opinion and not giving me grief for it. Believe me when I say I am 100% behind GB. Would love for it to just click for a lot of them. Good luck Harriet.

__________________

CF



Tennis legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 10074
Date:

Chris wrote:

Other countries may have the same problems but its GB girls I follow. Have done since the early 70s when I fell in love with Evonne Goolagong although she was Australian. So I have heard the same thing for a long time. Seen a lot of tennis and a lot of GB girls. Frustrating because they do have talent just not the ability to get the wins that we all hope for. Would like to see Harriet up there again and pushing into the top 100. What do you think of a coach out there somewhere teaching the art of serve and volley. Use to really enjoy watching that. Its how I use to play, still do just a bit slower. Thanks for letting me have my opinion and not giving me grief for it. Believe me when I say I am 100% behind GB. Would love for it to just click for a lot of them. Good luck Harriet.


Yeah, I'm similar. I mean I do have a lot of overseas faves who I follow, but that top 100 is absolutely massive (from my POV) and like a huge dangling carrot - pretty much guaranteed entry to all the slams, and the pay cheques that come with it, direct entry into most WTA 250's rather than the odd qualifying, LL, WC appearance, and crucially, all matches on a proper broadcaster, so you actually watch all the matches, rather than hoping an ITF event is being streamed, and one of the GB players is on an allocated streamed court - they're kind of like different sports. I guess the more numbers you have around that slam qual entry level, and we did have 4 competing here, and a couple more on the periphery, the more chances that someone could break through, but certainly a long way off your dream of 6+ girls in the top 100. 

I watch so much WTA on Prime, and can't help but wish there were a few more GB players involved in the events as well, especially as the WTA players we currently do have, Jo and Heather, are 30 and 29, been around for years, probably not many years left, and kind of feel a little bit stale, at least to me anyway.

 



__________________


Tennis legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 10074
Date:

Harriet is 2nd on Court 5 tomorrow, following a men's match. Play starts at 9.30am UK again.

They managed to get through 31 of the 32 women's matches today, with the one remaining suspended at 6-3 4-2.

__________________


Club Coach

Status: Offline
Posts: 582
Date:

I feel much more positive than others on here - I think the glass is half full at least, as regards British players.

2 things to really remember - we normally do badly on clay, so this is a bad point at which to assess where Brits are at, and Covid has altered the ranking system, making it far harder for players to make rapid rises up the rankings.

Looking to the future, Harriet is regaining form and looks to have a shot at making the top 100, which would of course mean playing top players the whole time, which would be likely to improve and fine tune her game.

Katie B remains our biggest prospect; the injuries haven't been kind, but this year has seen a big rise up the rankings and by the end of the year she should be back in the top 200 and pushing for a place back in the big time.

Fran has improved hugely over the last year, and Jodie B is beginning to look like a top player - they are both a distance from the top 100 at the moment, but progress is definitely possible.

Katie S has the talent, but for me, she needs to be playing more regularly and to make sure her mental state is tip-top - if she can overcome her issues, I feel she is probably our second best prospect behind Katie B.

Emma and Matilda also give hopes for that we have teenagers who will break through, so although Jo Ko and Heather are getting towards the tail end of excellent careers, I do feel we have players to be excited about and some who hopefully will break through to the top 100 - and from there players play other players at top level and then often their game massively improves.

I have a feeling that by the end of Wimbledon, we will all be feeling more positive about our Brits - the French Open is normally our low point of the year.

Oh and good luck and go Harriet; we are all willing you to make the tournament proper.





-- Edited by Andy Parker on Wednesday 26th of May 2021 04:15:41 AM

__________________
Andy Parker


Club Coach

Status: Offline
Posts: 667
Date:

Chris wrote:

Other countries may have the same problems but its GB girls I follow. Have done since the early 70s when I fell in love with Evonne Goolagong although she was Australian. So I have heard the same thing for a long time. Seen a lot of tennis and a lot of GB girls. Frustrating because they do have talent just not the ability to get the wins that we all hope for. Would like to see Harriet up there again and pushing into the top 100. What do you think of a coach out there somewhere teaching the art of serve and volley. Use to really enjoy watching that. Its how I use to play, still do just a bit slower. Thanks for letting me have my opinion and not giving me grief for it. Believe me when I say I am 100% behind GB. Would love for it to just click for a lot of them. Good luck Harriet.


 I'm in pretty much the same boat as you. In some ways it is the hope that kills you. Right now we've have a crop of players all aorund the same age who, 3 or 4 year ago looked like they could kick on and for whatever various reasons have not yet done so and some now don't look likely to.

However, I think there are more widespread and quite endemic issues at play which are hard and indeed almost impossible in onecase to overcome.

1 Tennis (womens) is perceived as a sport mainly played by more well off white girls and women even if that isn't actually the case. So, though tennis is played at some schools there is a perceived barrier, by some, not all, people on how to go to the next level. Tennis clubs, though  they have tried hard to change this immage, are still seen by many as being run by stuffy older people and "not for me". So the whole question of how do we identify top players and how do we develop them comes into play here.

 

2 There simply isn't enough exposure to the top players in the game in this country. What I mean by this is the chances for young aspiring tennis players to watch the top women in the game live is so limited. The unfortunate downgrading of the Birmingham tournament is a classic example of this. Pretty much now the only way to see, live, the top players is at Wimbledon where the ticketing sytem and the archaic queue make it potentially difficult for people not living near London to attend. I'd add to this the fact that tennis has very little exposure in national media and on free to air TV. I believe people can be inspired to take up the game by watching their "heroes" live. It was very noticeable at the last Birmingham tournament the greater diversity in the audience with Venus Williams playing.

3 There aren't enough tournaments at the lower level for our younger players to play regularly. This does need to be addressed so our young players can acquire ranking points to help them get into other tournaments. The weather doesn't help and our grass court season is very short so I would like to see us go all out to develop a major indoor clay tounament, like Stuttgart, at somewhere like the NEC. Or hardcourt. I realise this is difficult.

I'm not qualified to say anything about the technical ability of our coaches but there seem to be good British coaches out there and some are or have been coaching top players in the game.

As to today, really good luck to Harriet. I think she has a very decent opportunity to get through to the main draw. I wonder if her and Katie Boulter will be British number 1 and 2 in the not too far distant future?



-- Edited by HarryGem on Wednesday 26th of May 2021 05:12:31 AM

__________________


Satellite level

Status: Offline
Posts: 1435
Date:

Andy Parker wrote:

I have a feeling that by the end of Wimbledon, we will all be feeling more positive about our Brits - the French Open is normally our low point of the year.




Do you reckon? They'll need kind draws to put together many wins. The grass season is usually disruptive to form because our women are given WCs to levels above their ability, not withstanding that some of our women can play above their ranking on home grass.

WTA Nottingham might be their best chance to string wins together as the field is likely to be the one closest to their ability as there will very likely be a lot of withdrawals.

Birmingham current cut off is 57. Heather and Harriet are likely to be the WCs as things stand. Katie B may stay in Nottingham rather than play Birmingham Q. Our best chance of wins this week will come if any of Jodie, Fran or Katie S play ITF Nottingham rather than Birmingham quals.

Eastbourne reduced to a 32 draw will have a cut off close to 30. We'll find out in a few hours. 2 from Heather, Harriet and Katie B will be the WCs. QWCs will be whoever misses out on the MD, other Wimbledon MDWCs and players who miss out on Wimbledon Q usually taking up any remaining QWCs. I don't see any wins there.

There may be the odd gem of a result but I don't expect they'll be much to shout about without kind draws.

-- Edited by RedSquirrel on Wednesday 26th of May 2021 06:40:48 AM

__________________


Club Coach

Status: Offline
Posts: 582
Date:

I genuinely do think that things should pick up for some of our players when the short grass court season starts. A lot depends on the luck factor of good draws, but normally things feel better after Wimbledon than during the French Open.

I also think that it is worth saying that all the Old World countries are suffering a decline in fortunes - Spain, France, Australia etc, and that so many of the newer post-industrialised countries are now catching up and making tennis much more competitive globally. Go back 40 or 50 years and you would have seen about 20 Spanish players in the top 100, numerous French, Australian, American and some Brits, Germans and Italians - now you see masses of players from the countries which were previously part of the Soviet block like Romania and Slovakia for instance, and you are also seeing lots more Chinese players and players from countries that previously had no top players and sometimes no professional players.

All that means that a shift in the world order is happening and that with lots of countries now seriously challenging at tennis to create top players, it is now much more difficult to get to the top, and probably unrealistic with a 70 million population, to expect more than a handful of players to make the top 100.

I agree though with others that tennis is still perceived as a game for the white middle classes and that some of our coaches don't help that perception.

__________________
Andy Parker


Top national player

Status: Offline
Posts: 3384
Date:

Andy Parker wrote:

I genuinely do think that things should pick up for some of our players when the short grass court season starts. A lot depends on the luck factor of good draws, but normally things feel better after Wimbledon than during the French Open.

I also think that it is worth saying that all the Old World countries are suffering a decline in fortunes - Spain, France, Australia etc, and that so many of the newer post-industrialised countries are now catching up and making tennis much more competitive globally. Go back 40 or 50 years and you would have seen about 20 Spanish players in the top 100, numerous French, Australian, American and some Brits, Germans and Italians - now you see masses of players from the countries which were previously part of the Soviet block like Romania and Slovakia for instance, and you are also seeing lots more Chinese players and players from countries that previously had no top players and sometimes no professional players.

All that means that a shift in the world order is happening and that with lots of countries now seriously challenging at tennis to create top players, it is now much more difficult to get to the top, and probably unrealistic with a 70 million population, to expect more than a handful of players to make the top 100.

I agree though with others that tennis is still perceived as a game for the white middle classes and that some of our coaches don't help that perception.


 As the (single, poor)parent of a mixed race child, I actually find comments like this a much bigger problem, all you're doing is reinforcing a perception that tennis is white middle class but when was the last time you actually went and watched a junior ratings tournament in your local area.  My Son learned to play tennis at a club that whilst not one of the 'posh' clubs, is located in a village with one of the highest percentages of millionaires in the Country. Never did he experience any racism, in fact he is the one the adults loved and still ask me how he is because he was polite and, more importantly, a good player. Any elitism or snobbery in tennis in my experience has been down to ability. There is no more racism in tennis than any other part of society.  But this constant banging on about it creates the perception and it's that that causes the problem.  Funnily enough it doesn't seem to stop Eastern european parents from getting their kids into tennis. My son now runs tournaments and most of the participants are eastern european or black, very few white kids there and even less well off ones.



__________________


All-time great

Status: Offline
Posts: 5404
Date:

Andy Parker wrote:

I genuinely do think that things should pick up for some of our players when the short grass court season starts. A lot depends on the luck factor of good draws, but normally things feel better after Wimbledon than during the French Open.

I also think that it is worth saying that all the Old World countries are suffering a decline in fortunes - Spain, France, Australia etc, and that so many of the newer post-industrialised countries are now catching up and making tennis much more competitive globally. Go back 40 or 50 years and you would have seen about 20 Spanish players in the top 100, numerous French, Australian, American and some Brits, Germans and Italians - now you see masses of players from the countries which were previously part of the Soviet block like Romania and Slovakia for instance, and you are also seeing lots more Chinese players and players from countries that previously had no top players and sometimes no professional players.


 There are heaps of Italians (mainly men I think but there'sfew definitely also women) and Americans (not named Coco Gauff) and one or two Germans as well that are young and up and coming. Sure, there's more of a variety of players now ( and do not underestimate the influence of Li Na, Kei Nishikori and Naomi Osaka in Asia).

 

There's heaps of tennis courts here in NZ (indoor/outdoor/clay and hard/other possibly) but they don't really have any players of note (apart from Cam...smile)



__________________


Tennis legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 10664
Date:

Harriet about to start.

__________________


All-time great

Status: Offline
Posts: 6979
Date:

PaulM wrote:

Harriet about to start.


 Which  number Eurosport does anyone know ? I'm watching via Amazon Prime



__________________


County player

Status: Offline
Posts: 806
Date:

I think London is a prime example of tennis being an elitist sport in the UK. I live in central London and it's nigh on impossible to get public courts, there aren't that many and the bookings go within seconds of going live. Around London Bridge, Kennington, Clapham, Vauxhall and so on. And most of the indoor courts are in private clubs. My friend just bought a place in Putney which has a private court attached the apartments! Just crazy to me - I didn't even know that was a thing. To me this whole structure in the UK is very elitist, and makes it harder for children from non affluent backgrounds to get involved/stay involved.



-- Edited by wales1994 on Wednesday 26th of May 2021 10:06:52 AM

__________________
Come on brits :D


Tennis legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 55405
Date:

Julia Carrot wrote:
PaulM wrote:

Harriet about to start.


 Which  number Eurosport does anyone know ? I'm watching via Amazon Prime


 I don't know about number, sorry. 

It's on Eurosport player, on the long horizontal list of matches they're showing.



__________________
«First  <  14 5 6 7 814  >  Last»  | Page of 14  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard