Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Week 6 - ATP 500 - ABN AMRO World Tennis Tournament, Rotterdam, Netherlands (indoor hard)
Nix


Futures level

Status: Offline
Posts: 1899
Date:
RE: Week 6 - ATP 500 - ABN AMRO World Tennis Tournament, Rotterdam, Netherlands (indoor hard)


emmsie69 wrote:

Yes he has dual nationality and as far as I'm aware has lived in the UK since 2008 so no comparision to Brydan at all. As the parent of a dual citizen myself it really gets my goat to see people being torn down for not being a 'proper' brit'.


 If that was aimed at me emmsie I'm hardly tearing him down as I made clear I wish him well but just don't follow his results. Isabelle Wallace was totally British as far as I'm aware, but I don't follow her these days as she opts to play for Australia, so it's to do with allegiance more than nationality. As far as Bryden goes, his allegiance seems a bit questionable to me, even though it's nominally British. I don't mean to be harsh on him but it just seems that way because of where he plays and who he plays with and the circumstances of his changing allegiance. It doesn't mean I think someone of dual nationality can't call themselves British though but in sporting terms they can't play for another country and then claim to be a British player. 



__________________


Top national player

Status: Offline
Posts: 3391
Date:

Its a rant at anyone that questions a British citizens right to represent their country. Yes there are charlatans like Brydan but the vast majority that get it in the neck like Jo Konta legitimately represent their country.  They are sports people and of course they want to achieve the absolute maximum so I don't see an issue with what Bedene did. He was quite frankly done over by the ITF and I don't blame him for his decisions. 



__________________


Improver

Status: Offline
Posts: 12
Date:

emmsie69 wrote:

Its a rant at anyone that questions a British citizens right to represent their country. Yes there are charlatans like Brydan but the vast majority that get it in the neck like Jo Konta legitimately represent their country.  They are sports people and of course they want to achieve the absolute maximum so I don't see an issue with what Bedene did. He was quite frankly done over by the ITF and I don't blame him for his decisions. 


not defending Brydan but isn't his mother English?



__________________


Challenger level

Status: Offline
Posts: 2569
Date:

Hello Isca, I dont know if she is English, I do not doubt someone on here will know though. I post to say "Welcome" to the board.....couldn't just have you sneaking on like that ;)

__________________

 Its really not as bad as they say :)



Tennis legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 19402
Date:

Shhh wrote:

Hello Isca, I dont know if she is English, I do not doubt someone on here will know though. I post to say "Welcome" to the board.....couldn't just have you sneaking on like that ;)


 biggrinbiggrin



__________________


Tennis legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 19402
Date:

Isca wrote:
emmsie69 wrote:

Its a rant at anyone that questions a British citizens right to represent their country. Yes there are charlatans like Brydan but the vast majority that get it in the neck like Jo Konta legitimately represent their country.  They are sports people and of course they want to achieve the absolute maximum so I don't see an issue with what Bedene did. He was quite frankly done over by the ITF and I don't blame him for his decisions. 


not defending Brydan but isn't his mother English?


As Shhh said, welcome to the board Isca.  We always like new posters and new opinions.  Hope you stay around and join in when you can.



__________________


Tennis legend

Status: Online
Posts: 58267
Date:

Isca wrote:
emmsie69 wrote:

Its a rant at anyone that questions a British citizens right to represent their country. Yes there are charlatans like Brydan but the vast majority that get it in the neck like Jo Konta legitimately represent their country.  They are sports people and of course they want to achieve the absolute maximum so I don't see an issue with what Bedene did. He was quite frankly done over by the ITF and I don't blame him for his decisions. 


not defending Brydan but isn't his mother English?


Yes - extract from Wiki:

In April 2013, the LTA, the national governing body of tennis in Great Britain, were informed of Klein's desire to switch his nationality from Australian to British through the International Tennis Federation. A month later, it was announced that Klein had completed his switch to playing under a British licence. Despite being born in Rockingham, Australia, his mother was from Manchester, England, and therefore Klein was able to switch allegiance.

Welcome, Isca.



__________________


Improver

Status: Offline
Posts: 12
Date:

thank you so much for the warm welcome smile



__________________


Tennis legend

Status: Online
Posts: 42539
Date:

Isca wrote:

thank you so much for the warm welcome smile


 Indeed, welcome! 

 

As an add, re Brydan, it has never been clear to me why he swapped - most of his play seems to be in Australia or Asia, I dont think he plays any of the GB events really and  hasnt got his ranking anywhere near a level where he might play for the DC team etc. Other than getting some wild cards initially for grass court events (and would he not have got similar in Oz events if he had stuck as an Aussie), I am not clear how he benefitted? 

Wasnt Cam initially a Kiwi representative and came over to GB vest around the same time? Cam has clearly integrated into the GB system much more and played on the teams, but having got his ranking up to a decent level perhaps that affords him more freedom and cash to  be able to do that? 

 



__________________


Tennis legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 19402
Date:

JonH comes home wrote:
Isca wrote:

thank you so much for the warm welcome smile


 Indeed, welcome! 

 

As an add, re Brydan, it has never been clear to me why he swapped - most of his play seems to be in Australia or Asia, I dont think he plays any of the GB events really and  hasnt got his ranking anywhere near a level where he might play for the DC team etc. Other than getting some wild cards initially for grass court events (and would he not have got similar in Oz events if he had stuck as an Aussie), I am not clear how he benefitted? 

Wasnt Cam initially a Kiwi representative and came over to GB vest around the same time? Cam has clearly integrated into the GB system much more and played on the teams, but having got his ranking up to a decent level perhaps that affords him more freedom and cash to  be able to do that? 

 


I have always had the sensation that Cam and indeed Aljaz, both desperately wanted to represent GB whereas with Brydan, it was nothing more than a "flag of convenience".  In truth, I have never really taken to him and rarely comment (or follow) his matches.



__________________


Tennis legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 55661
Date:

I think it was pretty much purely a question of convenience for Cam too. (Which, personally, I don't have a problem with).

His parents have said they would have stayed with NZ if the NZ authorities had supported their son. But they were very angry the authorities didn't.

His mother is quoted as saying, that even though Cam was a great junior, the NZ federation did nothing and:

"We have been very disappointed with Tennis New Zealand's support of Cameron in the past."

They didn't give him hardly any funding and when they didn't pick him for a Davis Cup match (where the main guys couldn't play), his mum said:

"It was another sign that Tennis NZ weren't interested in Cameron, that they weren't interested in backing him," said Helen.

"We weren't disappointed, but it was like OK, this is where we're at, this is the reality of the situation, what can we do about it and where do we go from here?"

And their solution of where to go from here was the UK.

So, for Cam, I don't think he 'desperately' wanted to represent the UK - I think it was very much a question of self interest (which, again, I don't criticise - hard enough to make it as a tennis player)

For Aljaz, on the other hand, I do think he very much wanted to play for GB. He lived here already, for quite a long time, did all his tennis here, his girlfriend was here, his life was here.

I wonder what Jan Choinski's story is ..... I assume it's rather like Cam's but a little later down the road.

(And, yes, Brydan seems very much an Aussie and (probably?) would have stayed one if the media had ever got off his back about the racist incident)

__________________


Hall of fame

Status: Offline
Posts: 9410
Date:

Back to the subject of Rotterdam I see that a win today for Dan would lift him into the top 30 for the first time. Good incentive.

__________________


County player

Status: Offline
Posts: 828
Date:

Clearly winnable given Evans current form and his adeptness indoors. Monfils though has actually won the majority of his handful of titles on indoor hard courts. I think it's a toss up.

__________________


Tennis legend

Status: Online
Posts: 42539
Date:

EddietheEagle wrote:

Clearly winnable given Evans current form and his adeptness indoors. Monfils though has actually won the majority of his handful of titles on indoor hard courts. I think it's a toss up.


 Both seem in form. According to Jose Morgado tweets, surface is VERY slow, not sure if that plays into Dan's hands a little more to frustrate Monfils? We will see. 

Jamie and Neal win the first set doubles, down a break in set 2. If they win, we will have 3 pairs with GB players in Race Top 8 (live), and Neal will equal his CH ranking of 27 in live standings. Lots of incentive.  

 



__________________


Tennis legend

Status: Online
Posts: 58267
Date:

QF:  (Q) Henri Kontinen & Jan-Lennard Struff (FIN/GER) CR 89 (31+58) defeated Jamie Murray & Neal Skupski CR 53 (25+28) by 5-7 6-1 [10-6]  bleh



__________________
«First  <  1 2 3 4 5 6  >  Last»  | Page of 6  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard