I'm also wondering this. I watched a bit of his match here on lovestream.com/atp which was the first time I've seen him play (tho the livestream replay was freezing constantly on my phone so was much harder to watch than usual - anyone else found that this week?). I was pleasantly surprised by how much it was Evan dictating the outcome of the points. He basically seems to have a really nice game that would be good enough for the top 150 if he was able to cut down on the huge number of basic errors he made. Mike Cation said in commentary that he needed to just be giving more margin for error which makes some sense. He looks like someone who if he hit form could get some really good wins so I felt kinda hipeful about him after a first watch despite the poor result..... but i now feel less so after hearing more from those on this thread who've followed him more closely than me. Did you guys also feel hopeful based on gamestyle a while back but now you feel he's had time to learn a balance of consistency but hasn't learned/proved he can do it despite ample chance?
I was very impressed by Evan as an 18 year-old. Lots of power, athleticism and natural ball skill.
Then he was injured for so long.
Then played ITFs and I only saw a couple of little bits, here and there.
But then he started playing Challengers and it was all livestreamed.
And ....
My first feeling (as noted on here somewhere, a while ago) that is was just the move up that was an issue and that he had the classic problem on a big hitter who is used to winning points 'too easily' at ITF level - you see it often, the guys with a lot of power wind up their shots, blast it, and stand there admiring the shot because they know it's not coming back. And of course they miss a few but the gameplan works fine.
When they move up a level they realise (you hope) that you need to hit AND MOVE.
Evan absolutely categorically (it seems to me) refuses to 'bounce' when the other player hits the ball, he plays his shot and watches it, and then - god help - suddenly finds the ball has come back and panics. (This is a bit harsh - it's not all the time - but it's often enough). It has to be really, really drilled into someone to hit, prepare stance, bounce.
And only the 'hit' is the fun bit. The two other bits (prepare, bounce) are boring, tiring and 'uncool'. Hence, the need for it be drilled in. Especially if you find it tricky.
But Evan doesn't do it. Hence, he makes tons of mistakes. (He also makes mistakes due to really sloppy footwork even when he's got plenty of time, it's not quite the same issue, but it's all connected).
And I thought it was just the step-up that had caught him out. And that it would get better as he realised. But he doesn't seem to have (the last livestream match I watched was JUST the same).
It's similar to Kyle, in a way, (their games and physiques are not dissimilar, Evan is better at the net, Kyle's power is obviously one notch up) and Kyle really put a huge amount of effort into improving it. And it paid off. It's not his strong point and he may/may not have other, different issues. But he got tons better. Which enabled him to use his weapons better.
So, yes, Evan has a lot of natural talent and attributes for tennis, he's got a lot of potential. But I find it really worrying that he doesn't seem to have made progress in something that is 'easy' (but boring) to work on.
Liam has won less points in both sets and a lot more points have been played on his serve, particularly in the 2nd set, but it had looked as if he was going to get the job done.