Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Week 23 - Challenger (€127,000) - Aegon Surbiton Trophy, Great Britain - grass


Grand Slam Champion

Status: Offline
Posts: 4586
Date:
Week 22 - Aegon Surbiton Trophy, Great Britain (Grass) - E127K


As everyone knows by now I have little interest in doubles bar Slams when the better players are on show. Luke appears to be struggling in singles but a better overall player than Joe therefore Luke more entitled to the WC than Joe. He's more likely to progress. Rewarding players that don't make the grade with Wild Cards regardless of their intentions does nothing. So Luke and partner for me. I do really hope that Luke gives the singles one last crack, ideally drop the doubles while he does so. I find it interesting his singles form going down as double goes up.



__________________


Futures level

Status: Offline
Posts: 2016
Date:

Why has Ward been given a wild card? I'm confused, at least give to to players that are actively playing.

__________________

World renowned expert in Nordic tennis. 



Tennis legend

Status: Online
Posts: 41021
Date:

... or been top 100 within the last two years, contributed probably vitally to Davis Cup success and has been out for over 8 months after surgery to sort out some ongoing problems and needs reasonably high level matches at the start of the grass season.

Surely really not much reason for confusion.



__________________


Masters Series Champion

Status: Offline
Posts: 3819
Date:

David O'hare was there yesterday.
I'd understand the argument of only giving wildcards to benefit British players if we selected tournament levels that benefited British players. How many British players has a 127000 really helped? Putting on 4/5 42500 events would be a lot more beneficial than 100k plus ones IMO.

__________________


Futures level

Status: Offline
Posts: 2016
Date:

indiana wrote:

... or been top 100 within the last two years, contributed probably vitally to Davis Cup success and has been out for over 8 months after surgery to sort out some ongoing problems and needs reasonably high level matches at the start of the grass season.

Surely really not much reason for confusion.


 Why not got a protected rankings if been out injured? explain??



__________________

World renowned expert in Nordic tennis. 



Tennis legend

Status: Online
Posts: 41021
Date:

Vandenburg wrote:
indiana wrote:

... or been top 100 within the last two years, contributed probably vitally to Davis Cup success and has been out for over 8 months after surgery to sort out some ongoing problems and needs reasonably high level matches at the start of the grass season.

Surely really not much reason for confusion.


 Why not got a protected rankings if been out injured? explain??

 

I assume that he does have a PR but it will be well below the WR 151 of the last direct entrant since he had fallen out of the top 200 before he last played on the tour last September.

 



__________________


Grand Slam Champion

Status: Offline
Posts: 4586
Date:

Madadman wrote:

David O'hare was there yesterday.
I'd understand the argument of only giving wildcards to benefit British players if we selected tournament levels that benefited British players. How many British players has a 127000 really helped? Putting on 4/5 42500 events would be a lot more beneficial than 100k plus ones IMO.


 Exactly this. Given there are plenty ATP grass warm up events there should really be a spread. The lack of tournaments year round is concerning. These big challengers will be loaded and therefore almost no benefit to those ranked outside the top 300 as the results so far have shown on both men's and women's sides.



__________________


Futures level

Status: Offline
Posts: 2016
Date:

indiana wrote:
Vandenburg wrote:
indiana wrote:

... or been top 100 within the last two years, contributed probably vitally to Davis Cup success and has been out for over 8 months after surgery to sort out some ongoing problems and needs reasonably high level matches at the start of the grass season.

Surely really not much reason for confusion.


 Why not got a protected rankings if been out injured? explain??

 

I assume that he does have a PR but it will be well below the WR 151 of the last direct entrant since he had fallen out of the top 200 before he last played on the tour last September.

 


 Still he could be using this PR of 200 ish to enter into qualifying, and then following decent results take WCs. 



__________________

World renowned expert in Nordic tennis. 



Tennis legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 13909
Date:

Vandenburg wrote:
indiana wrote:
Vandenburg wrote:
indiana wrote:

... or been top 100 within the last two years, contributed probably vitally to Davis Cup success and has been out for over 8 months after surgery to sort out some ongoing problems and needs reasonably high level matches at the start of the grass season.

Surely really not much reason for confusion.


 Why not got a protected rankings if been out injured? explain??

 

I assume that he does have a PR but it will be well below the WR 151 of the last direct entrant since he had fallen out of the top 200 before he last played on the tour last September.

 


 Still he could be using this PR of 200 ish to enter into qualifying, and then following decent results take WCs. 


You would have to be a complete moron to use up a PR to enter qualifying when you could take a wild card into the main draw.



__________________


Futures level

Status: Offline
Posts: 2016
Date:

wolf wrote:
Vandenburg wrote:
indiana wrote:
Vandenburg wrote:
indiana wrote:

... or been top 100 within the last two years, contributed probably vitally to Davis Cup success and has been out for over 8 months after surgery to sort out some ongoing problems and needs reasonably high level matches at the start of the grass season.

Surely really not much reason for confusion.


 Why not got a protected rankings if been out injured? explain??

 

I assume that he does have a PR but it will be well below the WR 151 of the last direct entrant since he had fallen out of the top 200 before he last played on the tour last September.

 


 Still he could be using this PR of 200 ish to enter into qualifying, and then following decent results take WCs. 


You would have to be a complete moron to use up a PR to enter qualifying when you could take a wild card into the main draw.


The cut off for Surbiton would be too high?? 



__________________

World renowned expert in Nordic tennis. 



Tennis legend

Status: Online
Posts: 23478
Date:

Main draw - last DA 151. Qualies - last DA 397. Not sure what his PR is.

__________________


Futures level

Status: Offline
Posts: 2016
Date:

the addict wrote:

Main draw - last DA 151. Qualies - last DA 397. Not sure what his PR is.


The shame this highlights was the fact that there was not a more deserving candidate for a WC.  Broady and Glasspool have been in poor form for well over a year and face tough questions about their future in the sport at the end of this year,  Marcus Willis is a part time player.

 



__________________

World renowned expert in Nordic tennis. 



All-time great

Status: Offline
Posts: 5679
Date:

Or maybe it's that one of GB's best-loved players - a hero of several Davis Cup ties - is coming back from injury, and people would like to see him get a chance to do well. Affection and gratitude for someone who has given a great deal and who reached a high level through hard graft (his and his family's) and merit isn't necessarily a bad thing, is it?

I just wish he had a better draw ....

__________________


Tennis legend

Status: Online
Posts: 55569
Date:

For anyone a long way from London, just to say, the weather is truly horrible at the moment - raining, blowing a gale, cold.....

__________________


Futures qualifying

Status: Offline
Posts: 1791
Date:

CD is right about the weather! I'm just the other side of the river to Surbiton, it is truly horrible here - it has been blowing a gale and raining hard for a couple of hours, and it doesn't look like it will stop any time soon. The chances of any play today must be extremely small.



__________________
«First  <  16 7 8 9 1015  >  Last»  | Page of 15  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard