Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Week 17 - ITF $50K - Wénshān, China - Hard


Challenger level

Status: Offline
Posts: 2437
Date:
RE: Week 17 - ITF $50K - Wénshān, China - Hard


Want to build on this serving discussion - just a worrying thought in the back of my mind re Laura.

Just realised that Laura's coach is Mr Krajan, whose most famous charge was Dinara Safina......she who developed chronic serving yips while he was coaching her, having been an excellent server previously.

To be fair Safina went to #1 while he was her coach, but I recall Mrs Safina (her Mum and first coach) absolutely ripping him to shreds, claiming that her rise was already happening before he arrived as a result of previous coaching (not her, someone else) and that he brought absolutely nothing to the party, except for ruining her serve and destroying her confidence!!!!

Some pinch of salt needed here, as the Safin family are famously outspoken and, well, eccentric.

But slightly worryingly, Laura was playing her best tennis last year literally 1 or 2 weeks after he took over, and I find it almost impossible to believe that kind of impact can be attributed to him at all. It's true that her tactics appeared to have been tweaked for the better which I'm sure he influenced, but her movement and consistency, even on serve, was good (for her anyway!) post Olympics - and that doesn't happen overnight.

However, in my opinion both of these have got massively worse from the very first moment we saw her at the start of 2013. Her tactics are back to her old ways, her confidence and her serve has disappeared. I know she has been somewhat ill for while, but all these big one-sided third set defeats would suggest that either she doesn't have a tactical plan for these situations; or that she does have a plan but is ignoring it to shoot from the hip like in junior days (perhaps more likely); or that her fitness and stamina have deteriorated badly (because they were excellent at the US Open). The second and third of these things often go together.

Unless Laura was physically spent in the third set yesterday (which would be worrying and explain all the above), I think it is IMPOSSIBLE that Judy was instructing her to go for outright winners so early in points in that last set, especially as she was missing so often - having just won the second set, why would anyone go into all guns blazing, last chance saloon mode?! But that's precisely what she did....once again. I think its a fitness issue (mental and physical) and I think she almost can't resist pulling the trigger even out of position.

I am worried that Coach Krajan may have been rumbled........am I over-thinking this? 



__________________


County player

Status: Offline
Posts: 979
Date:

korriban wrote:

I am worried that Coach Krajan may have been rumbled........am I over-thinking this? 


Who knows?

I must say that I can't see the point of all this anguished speculation about Laura Robson. She quite sensibly doesn't share her own thoughts about what's been going wrong recently, and so nobody posting on this board really has the faintest idea. I'd venture a tentative hypothesis that she suffers from nerves more than most, and that's a pretty hard problem to solve - rather like telling a short person to get a bit taller.

Que sera, sera ...

(Although of course you'd have an empty forum if everybody followed my philosophy.)



__________________

"Where Ratty leads - the rest soon follow" (Professor Henry Brubaker - The Institute of Studies)



Challenger level

Status: Offline
Posts: 2437
Date:

Ratty's back!! Excellent.

You can treat nerves, or at least develop strategies to mitigate the problem, or even turn it into a positive (it's harder to make a short person taller, I'll give you that). But I don't think she comes across as more or less nervy than many others - she was almost nerveless at the US Open....how many match points did she save? I think her serving issues are technical (compounded, of course, by some nerves) because she rarely gets much over 50% first serves in, and it's hard to imagine her being nervous on first serves.

If I had a wish, it would be to find out what specific instructions of how to play she was given by Judy yesterday after going 1-2* down final set.....because I'm pretty certain it wasnt what we saw. Ormaechea was tight as a drum and the commentators we absolutely right in imploring her to keep the match tight and keep the ball IN PLAY.

Ho hum       



__________________


Tennis legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 39505
Date:

Ha Ha, Ratty, your bracketed last line was exactly the thought building in my mind as I read the rest of your post.

Gawd, not just here about British tennis, but the internet generally would be such a quieter place if folk didn't engage in speculation and counterspeculation in a multitude of subjects.

Now in many cases less speculation may arguably ( inded sometimes virtually inarguably ) be for the good, but we do no harm in this little corner and it appears to keep us amused, so maybe just smile knowingly, shake your head and let us be...

__________________


All-time great

Status: Offline
Posts: 5110
Date:

As in Phuket, 'our' duo, seeded fourth, will play the second seeds in the SF.
R1: Samantha MURRAY/Emily WEBLEY-SMITH (GBR/GBR) [4] defeated Sung-Hee HAN/So-Ra LEE (KOR/KOR) 7-6(6) 6-4
QF: Samantha MURRAY/Emily WEBLEY-SMITH (GBR/GBR) [4] defeated (WC) Ting LI/Kai-Lin ZHANG (CHN/CHN) 6-1 6-3
SF: Samantha MURRAY/Emily WEBLEY-SMITH (GBR/GBR) [4] vs. Miki Miyamura/Varatchaya WONGTEANCHAI (JPN/THA) [2]

__________________

Data I post, opinions I offer, 'facts' I assert, are almost certainly all stupidly wrong.



All-time great

Status: Offline
Posts: 5110
Date:

Sadly no final for our representatives in China:

SF: Samantha MURRAY/Emily WEBLEY-SMITH (GBR/GBR) [4] lost to Miki Miyamura/Varatchaya WONGTEANCHAI (JPN/THA) [2] 5-7 3-6

__________________

Data I post, opinions I offer, 'facts' I assert, are almost certainly all stupidly wrong.



Tennis legend

Status: Offline
Posts: 34280
Date:

... but they have both made new doubles career highs on the back of their semi-final appearance here - Samantha moves into the top 200 for the first time, up 16 at 200, and Emily moves up 7 to 216.

__________________

GB on a shirt, Davis Cup still gleaming, 79 years of hurt, never stopped us dreaming ... 29/11/2015 that dream came true!

GB top 25s (ranks, whereabouts) & stats - http://www.britishtennis.net/stats.html

«First  <  1 2 | Page of 2  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard