Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Favourite Matches


County player

Status: Offline
Posts: 811
Date:
Favourite Matches


Erm... Nadal vs Fed Wimbly Final 2009? I think Mr Roddick might dispute that with you. *wink* smile.gif The 2008 Final is definitely arguable... but very difficult to definitively say if it was "the best" (like the GOAT, you kind of almost can't pick just one because comparing across eras doesn't work and takes the players and matches out of their context of the time). Unfortunately I wasn't born until 1988, so there are many great matches that I can't "remember", and rely on them having been recorded in the past and being sold now (such as some of the classic Wimbly finals).

Knight -

Shanghai Tour Finals 2008 Murray vs Federer
- Probably on my list too. Of course, Fed said that he had a lingering back injury (I remember being there when he withdrew from Paris 2008 a couple of weeks before)... I don't know what to say to that, whether or not to give it credit that is... But a tightly contested match, and a great win for Andy. He kept his cool, kept his head, and just executed it so well.

I don't think Nadal vs Soderling makes it for me. Nadal was definitely not at his best with that knee injury, and I don't feel like Soderling was pushed enough... so not a classic in my mind. It just left me feeling kinda flat and unexcited, tbh.

I'd like to tender:

London Tour Finals 2009 Davydenko vs Federer - If you're talking in terms of tennis quality, sure you could probably find higher standards in other matches. Nevertheless, we're still talking excellent quality here.  For me though, the match is more about realised potential. Davydenko, ever the consistent top-10er, had been showing in the past few Masters tourneys a dangerous streak of form and absolute quality play, really proving why he deserved to be in the top 10. He kept up that kind of quality for the Tour Finals, and taking down Federer really showcased just what can make him such a dangerous opponent.

I don't have either of those two recorded, although the first four I mentioned in the op I do have on DVD.

EDIT: I hasten to add that it doesn't have to be just men's singles matches, could be a doubles match or a women's match or mixed dubs, or juniors. I'll see if I can think of more from my list and get back with those.


-- Edited by LadyTigress on Friday 14th of May 2010 05:29:32 PM

__________________
King of Slice
"He's on a one-man mission to bring the slice back to tennis." Inverdale



County player

Status: Offline
Posts: 811
Date:

This might be the first one so far given that doesn't fall under the "1 vs 2, arguably best match and best tennis" category - I said in the op that favourite matches don't have to fall under that format, and I was expecting people to come up with some weird and wonderful esoteric choices... I guess the category mentioned above is easy to spot and obvious choices to list! But I'm going to put this one out there... I won't be surprised if none of you agree with me, but it is one of my favourites and I will try to explain why:


Davis Cup March 2009: Great Britain vs Ukraine tie


I can understand why you might be thinking this is an unusual choice at this point. Andy wasn't there, and we lost! But here's why I have been recently re-watching it on DVD.


Hopefully people on here will know that lower-ranked tennis does not equal boring tennis. At the very least, if it's not a showcase of the best tennis in the world, it can produce just as excitingly tight, competitive matches. So right off the bat, this doesn't have to be viewed as an unexciting choice just because the top guys aren't in it.


First rubber, Goodall vs Marchenko. We had Marchenko grinding from the baseline, Josh displaying some excellent net play; Josh's stunning fight backs and saving of match points, Marchenko on a roller coaster of emotions from jubilation plunging to despair, and back again; the swings between Marchenko's strength at the beginning of the sets and then Josh's battling back in the end of the set, leading us to a tight tiebreak at the end on all three occasions had me sitting on the edge of my seat! And both guys showed some truly fantastic shots at time - resounding crosscourt and down-the-line winners on the run from both of them, and Marchenko at one point scored a second serve ace (!) which I actually can't recall having seen with my own eyes before or since. A great contest between two similarly ranked players, and after Marchenko's victory it wasn't a surprise that he went on and is where he is now.


Second rubber, Eaton vs Stakhovsky. Definitely more of a disparity here, with Eaton the underdog. What a treat to see some old style serve-and-volley! There's few enough players who use that style anymore these days. It was really fascinating to see how Stakhovsky reacted to that as well; ultimately he was of course in charge of the match but it was tricky for him to wrap his head around playing against that! And some of Eaton's Wimbly gumption showed through as well, taking a set off Stakh and he definitely tackled the match with an unafraid attitude which was the right way to go.


Third rubber, the doubles, Rossco & Flembo vs Stakh and Junior. What a battle w00t.gif
!!! Again, edge of the seat stuff, with everyone fighting so hard, and extra tension added in because GB had to win this one to stay in the tie. Stunning serving from Junior, absolutely thumping, and clever shot-making from Stakh, whilst Flembo & Hutchins at times even smarter in their plays. All the way to the final set and the final points - gripping stuff!

Fourth rubber the only damp squib for me. And then the fifth!! Eaton vs Marchenko. Eaton defeats a higher ranked opponent who has already defeated our number one fielded player?! There's that Wimbly gumption again. Another cracker of a contest again as well, going the full three sets, and of course Eaton rescued GB from being serving a bagel in the tie.


The atmosphere throughout was really great, the crowd was really into it, and everyone was really friendly. It was also a wonderful opportunity to see players from the Challengers and Futures tier of the Tour play, which as we know is hardly ever given any media coverage at all, let alone national tv coverage on the top channel. They themselves were bright, amiable and interesting people. I have fond memories of the tie, it was a great time, and I loved being there. awwbiggrinsmile



-- Edited by LadyTigress on Tuesday 18th of May 2010 04:47:36 PM

__________________
King of Slice
"He's on a one-man mission to bring the slice back to tennis." Inverdale



Futures level

Status: Offline
Posts: 2016
Date:

Sorry if no one has mentiond this, but if they havent i think many comentators would generaly regard it as a classic, really not sure of the year but

Australian open semi finals Safin v Federer,

Safins lob at match point for me remains the greatest shot in tennis history,was it 2005? not sure?

__________________

World renowned expert in Nordic tennis. 



Challenger qualifying

Status: Offline
Posts: 2380
Date:

yeh 2005, where Safin chases down the drop volley and sticks up the lob, brilliant

still think i prefer Federer's backhand pass on championship point against Nadal

__________________


County player

Status: Offline
Posts: 811
Date:

Indeed, 2005. Great match.

I wonder if anyone would venture any matches from this year? Have we even had any classics yet? Would Isner & Mahut count or would it not count because it dragged on so long that you could say it was boring and thus not a "classic" to watch?

__________________
King of Slice
"He's on a one-man mission to bring the slice back to tennis." Inverdale

«First  <  1 2 | Page of 2  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard