Of all tyrannies a tyranny exercised for the good of its victim may be the most oppressive.... those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience
strangely the 10Ks are harder than the spanish 15Ks!
Wonder if it's the time of year they're played? Perhaps the 10ks have relatively little competition nearby, whilst Spanish 15Ks march with French, British or other relatively popular tournaments?
I echo Rob's comment, Akhenaten - fascinating stats!
Surprisingly perhaps, Croatia 15s come out as the toughest futures in the world.
This doesn't surprise me - the Brits had a terrible time there, and when I've been looking up opponents recently, there have been quite a few who regularly get to the QFs and SFs of other Futures, but have gone out in R1 of the Croatian 15Ks they've played in.
Speaking as someone with a lot of experience of stuff like this outside tennis, I'd say there's little doubt that whatever flaws there may be in your system (and there are flaws in every rating/ranking system, however well thought out), it's far more accurate than the ATP rankings.
What really foxes me though is how you have managed to collate all the data, since tennis data is not that easy to collate in the way you must have done it - I'm seriously impressed! How do you do it in a way that allows you to keep doing these updates? (if you're willing to let me know but you think everyone else would be too bored by the details, feel free to pm me!)
__________________
GB on a shirt, Davis Cup still gleaming, 79 years of hurt, never stopped us dreaming ... 29/11/2015 that dream came true!
What really foxes me though is how you have managed to collate all the data, since tennis data is not that easy to collate in the way you must have done it - I'm seriously impressed! How do you do it in a way that allows you to keep doing these updates? (if you're willing to let me know but you think everyone else would be too bored by the details, feel free to pm me!)
'everyone', Steven? Surely you two can't be the only whizz kids on the site; what about Rob? Personally, though, I'm just delighted that you lot are here, so that we poor mortals can enjoy what you all produce!
I'm not sure how to post this without it being terribly boring, but here goes...
I've an Access database, with a Results, Players & Tournaments tables.
And I've a written a program that looks at the "http://www.stevegtennis.com/results/2008/" page checks the last modified date, and opens those pages where that's bigger than the last import date. eg. "http://www.stevegtennis.com/results/2008/f-canada1.txt"
If it's not in the Tournaments table in the Access Database it imports the details (eg. Date, Surface, Name) into that.
Then it deletes any entries in the Results table, and then goes thru each line in the text file and imports them into the Results table, if it comes across a new player it imports them into the Players table.
That's it. Anyone still awake??
Then with the results in the database, I can do what I like with queries.
And then there's also the program in Access that calculates the ratings.
Looking closer at this, Spain gets drags down massively by futures held in Canary Islands & Melilla (a Spanish port in Morocco).
Spain's average rating without these is 380, which puts them up to 5th (a place above Portugal).
It's the same thing for the USA futures - there are 2 very weak futures held in Hawaii with an average of 190 (just better than Sudan).
Without these Hawaiian events included, the USA has an average of 376, which puts them ahead of Portugal too.
If we assume these ratings are reasonably accurate (and as I've said before, I'm sure they're considerably more accurate than the ATP rankings), this comparison of different tournaments is potentially dynamite information for those players looking to target the tournaments that maximise their expected ranking points.
For the tournaments that are obviously going to be weaker because they're hard to get to (like the island tournaments you've mentioned here or the African tournaments), players can probably work it out for themselves, and the remoteness might stop them going there anyway. However, if some countries' Futures are weaker than those in surronding countries after taking into account their prize money level, or if it's possible to flag some individual tournaments which tend to be weak, players could make good use of that info as one element in planning a schedule as long as all the other players didn't know about it too! It could, for example, be a way of finding African-standard Futures without having to go to Africa.
Equally, the info could be used to avoid tournaments that are a lot stronger than you'd expect them to be, i.e. Ivory Coast seems to be a fair bit stronger than Nigeria.
Maybe new poster courtcrazy (see the Gatineau thread) would be interested in trying this out, since being in Gatineau suggests that group already try to identify good scoring opportunities - your data would just provide a more scientific way of doing it.
-- Edited by steven at 16:26, 2008-03-06
__________________
GB on a shirt, Davis Cup still gleaming, 79 years of hurt, never stopped us dreaming ... 29/11/2015 that dream came true!
The Brits have had a pretty good March, with most of our top players rising.
David Rice had the best March. Up 235 places to 860th - helped his excellent run to the quarter-finals in Zaragoza last week.
Dan Cox has had a pretty good month too, even if it's not returned him a single ranking point! His endeavours in Turkey have taken him up 105 places to 868th.
Matt Illingworth has followed up his great January & his awful February, with a good March. His good work in Portugal & Jersey has seen him rise 134 places to 957th.
Miles Kasiri was very consistent - quarterfinalist twice & 2nd Round twice, in Portugal & GB. Up 84 places to 596th.
Jonathan Kinsella & Kyle Brassington both had a good time in Canada, up 108 & 149 places respectively to 1237th & 1359th. Brassington's quarterfinal appearance was a nice surprise.
Chris Eaton had a bad month, falling almost 100 places down to 740th after having a bad time of it in Portugal. And Dan Smethurst and Josh Milton also struggled in Turkey (falling 88 & 50 places).
____________
Andy Murray reclaims 5th place from Nalbandian. A win over Federer always helps!
The two biggest March risers were the two unexpected finalists in Las Vegas - 20yo champion Sam Querrey (up 34 to 47th) & 21yo runner-up Kevin Anderson (up 76 to 76th).
Further down the rankings, the 17yo Pole, Jerzy Janowicz, rose dramatically, up 281 to 355th after winning the Liechtenstein Futures. Janowicz is in Exmouth this week.
The renaissance of Josh Goodall has begun. His Futures win in Exmouth and semifinal appearance in the Mexico City Challenger saw him rise 71 places in April to 351.
And with our young guns firing well in Bournemouth, we've seen their rankings rise impressively. - Josh Milton up 58 to 939. - Dan Evans up 75 to 944. - Marcus Willis up 159 to 1037. - Dan Smethurst up 175 to 1071. - Sean Thornley up 86 to 1076.
Alistair Felton has entered the rankings at 1647 after his great performance beating the no.1 seed in qualifying.
And one and only Mr. Robert Dee has entered the rankings at 3014 (out of 3038) after his much celebrated win over Arzhang Derakhshani (3026).
On the downside, Andy Murray fell from 5th to 8th (Ancic is now 9th). And Skupski & Kasiri both had a stumbling month falling 60 odd places each.
As we've hit clay season, here's the ratings by surface.
Clay 1 Rafael Nadal 2 Roger Federer 3 Novak Djokovic 4 David Nalbandian 5 David Ferrer 6 Nikolay Davydenko 7 Nicolas Almagro 8 Lleyton Hewitt 9 Guillermo Canas 10 Fernando Gonzalez
63 Andy Murray 235 Alex Bogdanovic 330 Jamie Baker 349 Richard Bloomfield 490 Joshua Goodall
Grass 1 Roger Federer 2 Andy Roddick 3 Rafael Nadal 4 Lleyton Hewitt 5 Tomas Berdych 6 Mario Ancic 7 Richard Gasquet 8 Novak Djokovic 9 David Nalbandian 10 Tommy Haas
28 Andy Murray 121 Alex Bogdanovic 257 Joshua Goodall 260 Richard Bloomfield 334 Jamie Baker 347 Miles Kasiri
Hard 1 Roger Federer 2 Novak Djokovic 3 Andy Roddick 4 Rafael Nadal 5 Nikolay Davydenko 6 David Nalbandian 7 Andy Murray 8 James Blake 9 Robin Soderling 10 Mario Ancic
159 Jamie Baker 175 Alex Bogdanovic 266 Richard Bloomfield 359 Joshua Goodall